Six new red-light cameras have appeared across different Staten Island intersections earlier this month, leaving many residents frustrated.
These cameras appear to be part of the NYC DOT’s initiative to activate more cameras throughout the city, which was announced earlier this year, with a goal of 600 new cameras by the end of the year. “Red light running is one of the most dangerous behaviors on our city’s streets and puts all New Yorkers at risk,” said NYC DOT Commissioner Mike Flynn in a January press release, “that is why we are taking immediate action to ramp up the city’s red light camera program.”
The new cameras have appeared on high-traffic intersections such as Hylan Boulevard and Midland Avenue, or Richmond Avenue and Richmond Hill Road. They add to the 63 active red light cameras and 230 speed cameras spread across the island.
Traffic cameras have been a source of frustration for Staten Islanders over the years. Many Staten Islanders feel that these cameras are less about safety and more about money. “It’s [also] a blatant cash grab,” says Staten Island resident Keith B, “I guarantee if the state were to pass a law saying that the fines must go to a charity and not the government, the cameras would go down nigh instantly.”
Others see the merits of the red-light cameras, like resident Mallory Duffy. “The speed cameras are annoying, but I understand why they’re in use,” she says, “I’ve definitely changed my habits and gone slower around schools and neighborhoods, which makes it safer for everyone.”
But even she feels that the cameras are more about generating revenue for the city than actual safety: “I wish the revenue from speeding tickets was directly invested into education or something else useful and not just a moneymaker for the city.”
While Queens pays the most in overall fines, Staten Island pays the most per capita. According to the Staten Island Advance, red light cameras on Staten Island have already generated $ 1.2 million for the city in 2026 alone. Mallory Duffy estimates that she and her husband have paid between $150 and $300 in fines. Keith B estimates he’s paid around $200 in fines.
When the NYC DOT was contacted to confirm whether or not there would be any more cameras, a representative said, “We don’t know yet.”
valariedamico 
Leave a comment